Structural Repair and Meter Fraud on 2018–2021 Compact Excavators: Boom Foot, Swing Bearing, Hour Records
I was on the low end of the trench with half a chicken wrap in my hand while the three-and-a-half ton machine descended upon its own bucket like a dog choosing its spot to lie and as the hydraulic cylinder bottomed out it made one report, not like a hydraulic cylinder bottoming out, but like a gun hitting the water, you actually felt it in the soles of your boots before your ears could register the impact and then a line of paint cooking on a flat surface unfit for such heat. On that site no one was yelling. The operator shut down, climbed out and looked at the boom foot with me and the two of us were just staring at a weld made probably 6 weeks ago by somebody that had a good machine and no procedure.
In all honesty, I had seen the signs 3 weeks before the cash went through and previously discounted all of the signs.
When interpreting a gauge, remember it does not give you the information you want, it tells you only where to look.
Almost everyone takes one reading on the repaired area and sees a number and feels reassured and puts it away; there is no other liar-catcher in the toolbox so cheap. That is backwards. It’s the DIFFERENCE: within that same gauge, in that same substrate; three readings on three locations of that same boom: boom foot plate (where it was fixed), twenty cm up on an un-repaired web and the arm nose (which in this era of machine repair is usually the last place touched with a spray gun and therefore the place left alone).
Then you see the Sealer and the Sealer is where the story is set down.

No human interaction with the bead after it has been extruded by the factory seam sealer makes for almost no tooling marks, a perfect crown bead and a clean line of engagement with the parent metal. Field sealer has been smeared out of a squeezing tube by an upside down human being working in a gravel yard, and it’s there that it shows–the bead moves off true, dragged in by a finger into a corner; and usually, there’s a smear on clean plate to the outside of the joint, where a gloved thumb wiped the excess. I have a pocket flash, just for this. Place the light essentially parallel to the surface and the tooling marks will throw a weld toe shadow, that the eye can’t detect with light, and once you saw a weld toe shadow going around the toe of a fillet weld, and it was never touched, you know it was a weld toe and not sealing a factory joint.
The other thing the loupe can see and the spray gun is unable to see is the places where the discoloration has occurred due to the heat. Even with wire brushing and repainting temperatures created by the welding create a halo of the “temper colors” (straw, then brown, then dull blue-grey), around the repair until the area is altogether blasted back to bare metal. A fillet dye penetrant check will show the toe part if the surface is ruptured by the defect or crack, but cannot tell you if lack of fusion is occurring a millimeter below the surface, and anyone claiming to have done a fillet penetrant check and obtained a clean side, is really telling you about their equipment, not about the weld.
Do not refer to pre-heat and interPass temperatures and post-Weld heat treatment as being refinements to a structural weld at a heat-treated section. They are the weld. Use of a propane torch at the boom foot in a gravel yard, and an IR gun reading the surface, is theatre–the interpass temperature is not determined by a procedure, but by the patience of the welder, and the area being measured is not the section. I’ve seen a very good man with 40 years in his hands put a beautiful cap on a boom foot (and it was never the cap) only to see it fail within a year.
The difficulty lies in the effects the repair has on the hardware that it impacts.
The boom foot attaches to the turret frame with a bolt group, with the bolts being preloaded with a specific amount of load which can only occur when the joint faces are in full contact and remain flat.
A field repair is going to create some distortion — it will as there is a heat affected zone that will contract as it cools and it will contract against the resistance of the structure already bolted down — and as a result of this distortion, the flatness that was assumed in the preload calculation will be compromised. This results in non-uniform clamping load in the bolt. It is subjected to a load bending moment which it was not designed for. When it begins to fatigue, fatigue begins at the root of the thread at the beginning engaged thread, as it is where the stress concentration is.
The second witness is free to use–grease purge condition. Remove the purge plug, or crack the fitting, and observe flavor of the fluid and the manner in which it flows. Fresh grease does not push as a ‘worm’ as it were. Water contaminated grease is streaked, dull in appearance and does not flow on the surface. Hot running grease emerges with a slight colour change from light to dark brown in the purge path, darkest at the bearing and if there is a slight sparkle of lightness in the grease (as if it contained just a fine flash of gold or silver when held up to the light) you can tell this is race grease and the bearing is letting you know its state of wear in a language you can read with your eyes.
There was a Sandbag on the floor of the one in the trench, and a Coffee ring on the Service Log and neither mean a thing.




